AP Statistics / Mr. Hansen
12/8/2004

Name: _________________________

Solutions to Pop Quiz

 

1.

As the number of trials increases, the sample proportion of successes approaches the true probability of the event. (Alternate form: As the number of trials increases, the sample mean approaches the true mean of a population.) Note that it is assumed that trials are independent. If you prefer to use mathematical notation, LOLN may be stated as

Here are paraphrased versions of some of the incorrect answers I saw:

   “As the number of trials increases, the probability approaches the relative frequency.”
   [Wrong since probability doesn’t approach anything. Probability already is something, namely the long-run relative frequency of success. The student meant to say that the sample proportion approaches something.]

   “The event approaches the true probability.”
   [Wrong since “event” is not a number; it is an event. The sample proportion of the event—or you could say the observed proportion of successes—is approaching the true probability.]

   “The long-run relative frequency approaches the observed sample proportion.”
   [Wrong; stated backwards.]

   “In the long run, the long-run relative frequency approaches the probability.”
   [Essentially correct, but circular, since “long-run relative frequency” is already defined to equal probability. It would be better to say, “In the long run, the observed relative frequency approaches the probability.” Now, you could respond by saying that that statement is also circular, and guess what? You would be right. LOLN is, at its root, nothing more than a tautology, by which we mean a statement that is self-evidently true by virtue of how the ground rules have been set up. In this case, the ground rule—namely the definition of probability as long-run relative frequency—forces the LOLN to be true.]

 

 

2.

250, since the trials are independent

Explanation: LOLN makes no attempt to “settle the score” or “even things out.” Instead, the imbalance that may be present in any initial short run (and by convention, any finite sample is considered to be a short run) tends to be diluted by the later trials. Interestingly, although the percentage error tends to zero in the long run, the expected size of the absolute error keeps growing and growing as the sample size increases!

You may ask, “Mr. Hansen, are you saying that if I flip a fair coin 1 million times, the absolute discrepancy between the head count and the tail count will probably be greater than if I flipped the same coin only 1,000 times?” The answer is yes! However, the relative error (i.e., the percentage difference between the observed head proportion and .5) will almost certainly be smaller.

 

 

3.

P(ace) = 4/52 = 1/13
P(ace | club) = 1/13, since there are 13 clubs, one of which is an ace

Since the probability of ace is unchanged by the additional information of having a club, the events are independent.

Although P(ace | club) = 1/13 can certainly be calculated by common sense, you may also use the conditional probability formula:
P(ace | club) = P(ace
Ç club) / P(club) = P(ace of clubs) / P(clubs) = (1/52)/(13/52) = 1/13.

Note that independence can also be established by showing that P(club) = P(club | ace) = 1/4. You do not need to do this, however, if you already proved P(ace) = P(ace | club) = 1/13 above. In other words, if event A is independent of B, then B is also independent of A. (Finally, common sense prevails.)

Additional note: There is another equivalent check that you can perform. It turns out that two events are independent iff the probability of their intersection equals the product of their probabilities. Students are often tempted to say P(A
Ç B) = P(A) · P(B), perhaps because they “learned” this rule in an earlier class. THIS RULE IS NOT TRUE IN GENERAL. IT IS TRUE IFF EVENTS A AND B ARE INDEPENDENT. However, since “iff” means “if and only if,” the rule is quite useful for checking for independence.

By this check P(ace
Ç club) = P(ace of clubs) = 1/52, and P(ace) · P(club) = (1/13) (1/4) = 1/52. Since the two answers are equal, the events are independent.